Fixed those subs, thanks Marco717 and EK_

I found this one (but don't own a copy):

The second one is much more complete but the Identification numbers/specs are the same.

Hello folks,

I've got another duplicate listing. This one is the film Whiplash. (keep this one) (delete this one)


I've got another duplicate listing. This one is the film Whiplash.

Those are not duplicates. The second one is for the original short film.

Merged all of those. Thanks for the heads up.

Regarding above.

There is not enough info with release @144999 to determine if it is identical to release 148410.

If you know anything about Criterion Collection, there are often represses (DVD sets) that are different from original editions - with identical identification codes.

I've left a comment on the duplicate, but I wouldn't be holding my breath.

But anyway, I don't think we should keep releases just because they might be different. Users should provide the differentiating information. Even the guidelines say that "In order for [unique objects] to be accepted, you must provide enough information to distinguish the different versions of a object."

I mean otherwise we might as well keep every single submission with non-sufficient info just because it might be different. There should be at least some sort of indication of the differences.

Merged, thanks oteis.


User error! Duplicated original when attempting to "Add One Like This"

fixed, thanks oteis and EK_
Not a duplicate, but there is something wrong with it.

fixed, thanks for the heads up kwulf

merged, thanks BadMoon

merged thanks sixandnine

140347 has more info, both the same Criterion release

Looks like exactly the same

One is PAL, the other NTSC, apart from that it looks the same. Even Canadian classification... Region 1 is not logic for PAL. I think needs a proper update.

merged all these apart from those Yellow Submarine subs, thanks all

These appear to be the same release. Please correct me if I'm overlooking some minor details:


Possible Dupe:

I think they are same release.

The point is to edit the originals and add data.

I just wanted to point out that the dupe might be used as datasource when merging...

The point is to edit the originals and add data.

Say this to sTemwinder7
Not to mention all the film duplicates he's creating....

^ Not sure how to edit a forum post. Please ignore my comment, the images are different.

Appear to be the same release - check images


Login or Register to post a reply to this topic.